Getz/Gilberto - João Gilberto, Stan Getz
🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Listen Party: 3/31/25
Released: 1964
Genres: Bossa Nova, Samba-Jazz, Cool Jazz, Samba-Canção
Tags: mellow, tropical, warm, soft, summer, romantic, peaceful, calm, soothing, male vocalist, acoustic, love, female vocalist, lush, bittersweet, longing, sentimental, sensual, happy, uplifting
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Another album by an artist I’d never heard of, but one glance at the track listing, and I immediately recognized The Girl From Ipanema. A little bit of research on Wikipedia tells me that while it was not the first recording of the song, this version by João Gilberto and Stan Getz is the first to feature any English lyrics (performed by Astrud Gilberto, João’s wife), and therefore the first to go mainstream worldwide.
The Gilbertos perform all of the vocals on Getz/Gilberto, with João also performing on the acoustic guitar. Bossa Nova, if you didn’t know, is essentially Samba with the distinctive rhythm performed on acoustic guitar. I’m reminded of Seu Jorge’s Portuguese, acoustic David Bowie covers from the Life Aquatic soundtrack.
Stan Getz joins in on Getz/Gilberto with a tenor sax solo, giving everything a cool jazz flavor. I’m not sure if it’s a stylistic choice by Getz, or perhaps the limitations of mid-1960s recording technology, but the sax sound is especially raspy. It grates on me very quickly, and I found myself wishing that Getz/Gilberto had dropped Getz. Sorry Stan. I’m sure more seasoned Jazz and Bossa Nova listeners would disagree.
I did really enjoy the Boss Nova sound though. It has such soothing, mellow, and sophisticated qualities. I imagine it would make the perfect complement to an upscale cocktail party. I’ve never really understood what Bossa Nova was, much less appreciated it. I think that makes Getz/Gilberto the most boundary-expanding Strange New Places album I’ve listened to yet, and that’s pretty exciting.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
Just when I think I won’t recognize anything on an album, I’m proven wrong. The Girl from Ipanema opened Getz/Gilberto, and of course, I knew it. I’m not sure I’d heard it in Portuguese before, but it instantly oozed that signature Brazilian cool.
The entire album was incredibly relaxing—so much so that I ended up using it as background music while studying, something I’ve never done with these albums in this project before. The calm, breezy bossa nova rhythms and non-English lyrics made it a perfect fit.
While the album was a bit one-note, it was an enjoyable note, and its smooth, laid-back atmosphere made for a refreshing change of pace from my usual listening.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
This album getz its songs into my herto
I played in a jazz band in college and bossa was a big part of the repertoire so many of these songs are familiar to me only because I played them. It takes me back to that time of learning so much about music and playing so much.
This is quite a lovely album that just vibes its way thru. Great musicality and playing. The english verses on Girl from Ipanema are a treat. However, its a bit TOO chill for my tastes and it all started to just blend together and fade into the background. Not an album I'm going to reach for.
That being said: if I'm ever at a pool party in the summer sun with a fruity drink in my hand, I want this album in my ears.
Submit Your Review
(Pronounced 'Leh-'Nérd 'Skin-'Nérd) - Lynyrd Skynyrd
🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
Listen Party: 3/28/25
Released: 1973
Genres: Southern Rock, Blues Rock, Hard Rock
Tags: male vocalist, energetic, sentimental, warm, bittersweet, passionate, melodic, pastoral, love, uplifting, rhythmic, playful
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
I’m genuinely surprised I didn’t hate a Lynyrd Skynyrd album. Sweet Home Alabama and Free Bird were always just so-so songs for me. I was aware of the Confederate flag flying antics. And that’s about everything I knew about the band.
I did have to pause to consider whether I wanted to listen to a band that aligned themselves with the Confederate flag. Ultimately, I discovered that every single member of the original lineup on (Pronounced 'Leh-'Nérd 'Skin-'Nérd) is dead. And in that case, I feel ok giving the album a listen to understand its importance in pop music history. It’s easier when I don’t feel like I’m actively contributing to shitty behavior.
The album is mostly filled with music that doesn’t actively grate on me. In my book, that’s a classic 3-moon rating. But there’s a couple songs that to my surprise, I actually enjoyed, which was enough to push it to 3.5.
Tuesday’s Gone is one of those I-didn’t-know-I-knew-that-song songs for me. Those are always fun to (re)discover. I’m certain I’ve heard it in a movie, so I googled it. It’s been featured in a few, but I almost definitely know it from the closing scene of Happy Gilmore.
Gimme Three Steps is just kind of a fun rock’n’roll song.
But that’s it. “If I separate the art from the artist, I KIND of like it”, is not exactly high praise, but it’s more than I expected for Skynyrd’s first album.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
Yeah, this sounds like Lynyrd Skynyrd alright. It’s the soundtrack to every Budweiser or Dodge Ram commercial from the early 2000s. This is southern-fried rock, brother!
I had no idea the opening song from Happy Gilmore (Tuesday’s Gone) was a Lynyrd Skynyrd track. I was ready to dismiss this album entirely, and then that familiar guitar opening hit, and suddenly, I was transported back in time. They earned at least half a star just for that moment alone. The rest of the song was prettier than I expected—whining, bending guitars, strings swelling in the background, giving the whole thing a somber yet oddly hopeful tone.
After that, the album starts to dip for me. Gimme Three Steps sounds like a generic ‘70s classic rock song, with a chorus effect on the vocals I don’t particularly love and a drum mix that feels oddly muted.
I have to say, I didn’t expect a social justice song from Lynyrd Skynyrd. Things Goin’ On is a critique of war spending, misplaced priorities in government/not taking care of the people, and what even sounds like a bit of environmental concern? The message is unexpected, but musically, this one just didn’t work for me—it’s too jangly and funky in a way that didn’t land.
Mississippi Kid was probably the most interesting track on the album. It leans heavily into Delta blues, with bluesy progressions and slide guitar. If the production were a little rougher, it would feel right at home on a record 40-50 years older.
And, of course, the album closes with Free Bird—the one song I knew I knew before listening. I don’t think I’ve ever sat down and given it a dedicated listen, but I’ve heard it countless times in the background of bars, movies, and ironic concert requests. The guitar solos are, of course, impressive, but if I’m being honest, I found myself a little bored. Much like the album as a whole, it’s well-executed, but it doesn’t particularly move me.
Overall, this one was a miss for me, aside from a few moments of nostalgia and some interesting blues elements. Maybe I’m just not enough of a Free Bird kind of guy.
Liz 🌕🌑🌑🌑🌑
This album pronounced ɪts weɪ ˈɪntu maɪ hɑrt
I actually recognized over half the songs on this album which kind of surprised me. I didn't realize I knew that much Lynyrd Skynyrd. I don't know a lot about the history of music like this, but I just kept feeling like "why is they so big? this isn't anything special" Feels like just mediocre bluesy rock with a southern twist. I feel like I'm missing something here.
Like it's fine. It's competent. Free bird is long and kind of makes sense as to why it's popular; it has that epic quality. But even other hits like Simple Man or especially Gimme Three Steps just feel bland.
Favorite song I think is actually Mississippi Kid as I kind of like how it dug more into the southern sound. And the world needs more slide guitar.
Submit Your Review
The Number of the Beast - Iron Maiden
🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
Listen Party: 3/27/25
Released: 1982
Genres: Heavy Metal
Scene: New Wave of British Heavy Metal
Tags: energetic, male vocalist, anthemic, melodic, heavy, passionate, epic, history, war, violence, death, rebellious, technical, rhythmic, triumphant, infernal, nocturnal, dark, apocalyptic, uplifting
Claire
🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
I like Just-John-that’s-it-that’s-the-reviewer’s-name™’s take of an intentional ironic humor behind the goofy, over-the-top production and presence of Iron Maiden. That almost makes it more palatable to me. Like, “wouldn’t it be funny if this were a band - and oh wait, it is!”
I don’t know much about heavy metal, and don’t have a trained ear for it. But I’m not convinced that Iron Maiden isn’t taking themselves completely serious on The Number of the Beast. It seems like a genre that is about pushing things to the extremes. What is the most rock’n’roll that rock’n’roll can get? A spectacle of loud, raucous music with epic guitar solos and plenty of satanic imagery.
This is my first heavy metal album, and I have trouble distinguishing one song from another. I suppose that if I stick with this project long enough, I’ll gain an appreciation for the nuance from artist-to-artist and album-to-album. But right now, “The Number of the Beast” is basically everything I thought heavy metal was, and I never really liked that genre.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
I’m not a fan of metal. But even with my general ignorance—or apathy—toward the genre, Iron Maiden has always stood out to me. Something about their image has always felt more fun, more over-the-top, fully embracing the big goofy monsters on their album covers and tshirts. There’s a sense of spectacle here that a lot of their contemporaries seemed to lack - in a genre filled with spectacle.
The album kicks off with Invaders, which, if not for the sheer number of guitars, almost sounds like an Aquabats song—fast, frantic, and theatrical. Children of the Damned slows things down and leans into something a bit more serious, but it still feels like a B-horror movie from the ’80s.
Bruce Dickinson’s vocals are undeniably impressive, soaring over everything, but even he gets a little lost in the mix of infinity guitars. The musicianship is top-tier and exactly what I would expect from this era of metal—big riffs, intricate solos, and harmonized guitars.
Lyrically, there’s a lot going on here: epic battles, sex work, literal face melting, Satan (naturally), and the exploitation of Indigenous Americans. It’s a wide range of themes. The Vincent Price-esque voiceovers scattered throughout only add to the album’s cinematic qualities, mirroring the horror action slasher movies popular at the same time.
At only eight tracks and 40 minutes, the album is surprisingly quick listen—but I see that as a positive. It never overstays its welcome. I had fun listening, but I can only have so much fun before it starts to feel too one-note or exhausting. Considering Iron Maiden has released like 40 more albums, I know there’s plenty more to explore if I ever want to, but The Number of the Beast gives me enough without dragging things out.
Gangland brings in a swinging, galloping rhythm that keeps the energy up all the way through to the finish. Hallowed Be Thy Name is a great closer—the tolling bells letting us know time is almost up. This one stood out the most to me, but honestly, this album might be the most even I’ve reviewed so far. No real duds, no real mind-blowing standouts—just consistently solid, high-energy fun.
The only other metal band I’ve really spent much time with is Blind Guardian, and their influence from Iron Maiden is obvious. The medieval imagery, the harmonized guitars, the cinematic voiceovers…
If Iron Maiden is having fun with this, not taking themselves too seriously, and their fans are in on it, then I’m having fun too. If this is actually super serious and I completely missed the point… then I sincerely apologize to any Iron Maiden fans I may have offended.
lIZ
🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
This album did a number on my heart
I went into this dreading having to listen to a full Iron Maiden album. I had heard "Run to the Hills" and "Number of the Beast" before and, while they are fine, it was definitely not music I go for.
While this album was definitely packed full of that 80s metal sound, I didn't hate it as much as I expected. The singing did grate on me after half a song, but I was actually pleasantly surprised at how clean the mixing was.
Much like my comment about Dire Strait's self titled album, this was really well balanced and every instrument and vocal had space in the mix. It was certainly aggressive and metal, but not an overwhelming ear-blasting thing that I have heard in other metal albums. It showed surprising restraint and I think the album was all the better for it and no less 🤘
Sputnik Music
Critic’s Review
“…The Number of the Beast was very influential and commercially successful, The Number of the Beast can be declared a classic in the world of metal….”
Submit Your Review
Dire Straits - Dire Straits
🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
Listen Party: 3/26/25
Released: 1978
Genres: Roots Rock, Blues Rock
Tags: rhythmic, male vocalist, mellow, warm, calm, playful, atmospheric, poetic, bittersweet, urban, soft, technical, melodic, introspective, lush
Claire 🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
Why do I hate the sound of 70s classic rock so much? The whole thing smacks of effort, man. Like we get it, Mark Knopfler, you're good at guitar. You don't have to put a solo between every sung line. And when you do solo, you could at least do the decent thing and put some distortion on that thing. My favorite moments on Dire Straits’ self-titled album were the ones that sounded the least like “Sultans of Swing”.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
The album opens with Down to the Waterline, and from the first few notes, it’s clear that Knopfler’s fluid picking is front and center. His playing is the defining feature of this band—elevating the guitar almost to the role of a second vocalist.
It can lean toward the self-indulgent at times, and it’s a great example of why pure musicianship doesn’t always translate into the best, most balanced songs.
Water of Love leans more into a ’70s classic rock and country-western sound, not that distinct early-’80s Dire Straits style I mostly associate with the band. Setting Me Up continues this twangy, country style. The rhythmic, bluesy picking drives the song forward, making it sound like something that I’d be blasting while running from ol’ Johnny Law in a getaway car across the backroads of Arizona in the 1970s.
Then comes Sultans of Swing, which immediately shifts back to their signature sound. I think KBCO requires this song to be played at least three times per day and takes me back to driving across the dam road late at night.
Most of the rest of the album keeps up the energy, full of bluesy licks and extended solos. In the Gallery even throws in a reggae-inspired rhythm, a nice contrast that keeps things from feeling too one-note. Wild West End is a more tender, stripped-down track, a love letter to a London neighborhood that feels worlds apart from the album’s otherwise American-leaning sound. Speaking of which, I was surprised to realize they’re actually from the UK—I always assumed they were an American band.
Vocally, Knopfler is the band’s weak point. He’s not a particularly strong or unique singer, and I get the sense that he’s a music nerd who just ended up in charge. Given how much space the guitar takes up, I wouldn’t be surprised if the band dynamic eventually led to some tension. He’s undeniably a virtuoso, but I can’t help but wonder if his bandmates ever got tired of waiting for him to wrap up a solo.
I understand why this album wouldn’t be for everyone—if extended licks and intricate fingerpicking aren’t your thing, it can start to feel a bit tedious. For me, it’s an enjoyable listen, but only if I’m in the right mood.
Liz 🌕🌗🌑🌑🌑
This album was dire in my heart.
What a slog. Like, I know it's about the guitar and stuff and I've heard Sultans of Swing more times than I can count, but I just cant bring myself to care about this album at all. It's just kind of boring.
Giving some moons just because I do like the mixing on this album. Everything is very clear and has its own space. The drums are nice and crisp, the dialog between vocals and guitar is very well balanced and it just sits very nicely.
If only the music was more enjoyable
AllMusic
Critic’s Review
“Dire Straits' minimalist interpretation of pub rock had already crystallized by the time they released their eponymous debut. Driven by Mark Knopfler's spare, tasteful guitar lines and his husky warbling, the album is a set of bluesy rockers. And while the bar band mentality of pub-rock is at the core of Dire Straits -- even the group's breakthrough single, "Sultans of Swing," offered a lament for a neglected pub rock band -- their music is already beyond the simple boogies and shuffles of their forefathers, occasionally dipping into jazz and country. Knopfler also shows an inclination toward Dylanesque imagery, which enhances the smoky, low-key atmosphere of the album. While a few of the songs fall flat, the album is remarkably accomplished for a debut, and Dire Straits had difficulty surpassing it throughout their career.”
Submit Your Review
Ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space - Spiritualized
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
Listen Party: 3/25/25
Released: 1997
Genres: Space Rock Revival, Art Rock, Neo-Psychedelia, Dream Pop, Symphonic Rock, Shoegaze, Noise Pop, Blues Rock
Tags: drugs, lonely, melancholic, psychedelic, space, dense, romantic, atmospheric, male vocalist, eclectic, breakup, introspective, bittersweet, Wall of Sound, lush, love, sad, existential, hypnotic, longing, sentimental, alienation, epic, spiritual, melodic, ethereal, warm, depressive, soothing, poetic, progressive, mellow, surreal, noisy, cold
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
I’d never heard of Spiritualized before, but the opening track immediately set an epic, cinematic, and relaxing tone. It’s sad, beautiful, and haunting, and the unexpected “I can’t help falling in love with you” refrain at the end was a surprise. If the rest of the album stuck to this formula, I could see myself coming back to it.
But then Come Together kicks in, and it sounds like a completely different band. High energy, wailing harmonica, horns, and a relentless, droning—was that even the same singer? Either way, I found myself preferring the slower, more ambient material. Looking at the track lengths, I could already tell this album might not be for me.
The middle section mostly blurred together for me, moving between frantic, chaotic energy and slower, sprawling songs. Home of the Brave was the standout here, most closely matching the feel of the title track. I could see using the softer songs as background music for work or study, but the frequent shifts into high-energy noise kept pulling me out of that headspace.
Then there’s Cop Shoot Cop, a 17-minute closer that embodies the whole album—oscillating between soothing ambience and total chaos. And I’m sorry, but unless it’s The Decline by NOFX, I’m not giving a 17-minute song repeat listens. Overall, this album was a miss for me. There were bright spots, but the overall style just isn’t my thing.
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Another band that I’m hearing for the absolute first time. It’s hard to understand exactly how Spiritualized passed me by entirely. With The Stone Roses, I was 6 when they released their self-titled album. But “Ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space” was released in 1997 - the same year as Blink-182’s “Dude Ranch”, an album I absolutely wore out. I’m thinking Spiritualized is one of those bands that were well-known in the UK, but never really found a market in the US. That, and this is an album that front-to-back, is about drug addiction. Maybe a 14-year-old in an American land-locked suburb was not the target market.
“Ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space” alternates between soothing, spacey, shoegaze and edgier, noisier bluesy rock. As the album progresses, the cycle accelerates, and the edgy, noisy bits grow edgier and noisier. This is almost certainly a deliberate choice by Jason Pierce to mirror the cycle of getting high and crashing into withdrawals. The final track is seventeen minutes of alternating cool jazz and pure noise.
This is a museum album for me - lots of artistic merit, but not necessarily something I want hanging on my wall. I can appreciate what the artist is doing, but I have a hard time imagining myself listening to the album all the way through ever again.
I do enjoy those spacier, shoegazier songs. “Ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space”, “Come Together”, “I Think I’m in Love”, “All of My Thoughts”, “Stay with Me”, “Home of the Brave”, and “Cool Waves”.
But songs like “The Individual”, “Cop Shoot Cop…”, “Electricity”, “Broken Heart”, and “No God Only Religion” are harder to appreciate on their own. And maybe that’s the point. In life, you can’t have the good without the bad. You can’t have the high without the low.
Except that it’s 2025, and I can make playlists easily now. Maybe someday somebody will invent a kind of heroin that works the same way.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Ladies and Gentlemen, this album floated its way into the space of my heart.
Oh wow that was a treat! Never heard of this artist before but I'm glad it came up since that was a delightful album. Lots of good songs and the vibe changed up quite a bit. Love how a lot of the songs had a good rolling feel. I got a lot of pink floyd vibes from one of the songs that made me wonder if they were quoting some of David Gilmour's work.
Yeah I'm here for the vibes and the experimentation. Kind of surprised I hadn't heard of this album given my tastes in music.
AllMusic
Critic’s Review
“Spiritualized's third collection of hypnotic headphone symphonies is their most brilliant and accessible to date.”
Submit Your Review
Rubber Soul - The Beatles
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Listen Party: 3/24/25
Released: 1965
Genres: Pop Rock, Folk Rock, Psychedelic Pop, Folk Pop, British Rhythm & Blues
Tags: melodic, love, male vocalist, bittersweet, romantic, autumn, mellow, melancholic, eclectic, sentimental, introspective, longing, happy, warm, spring
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
My understanding of Rubber Soul is that it sits at the transition from boy-band-Ed-Sullivan-Show-Beatles to traveling-to-India-and-dropping-acid Beatles. And you can definitely hear elements of both iterations here. I think that makes it a great first album of theirs to listen to.
Oh yeah, this is my first full listen-through of any Beatles album. Can you believe that? I know so many of their songs of course. It’s damn-near impossible not to. I tried to keep track of which songs I’d definitely heard before a full listen-thru, and Rubber Soul is batting over .700 in that department. Even then, it’s sometimes hard to know if I recognize a song because I’ve definitely heard it before, or because it’s The Beatles and they make the most familiar sounding music in the world.
I found the illustrated-typography treatment of “Rubber Soul” for the cover art pretty interesting. It is so quintessentially 1960s hippie-movement, and came out four years before Woodstock. It has me wondering if Rubber Soul was essentially the prototype for distorted bubble letters that we associate with bell bottoms and psychedelic drugs/ music. I haven’t found a satisfying answer to that question, but the designer who did the illustrated text on Rubber Soul was a man named Charles Front, who was in fact a pioneer in that aesthetic. But let’s get to the music.
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
“Drive My Car” - I can’t hear it without thinking about starting a road trip with my brother at the crack of dawn in the Northern California redwoods. This song came on his playlist, and he decided to honk the horn to the rhythm of “a-beep-beep, beep-beep yeah”. Instead the crappy rental subcompact’s horn just stuck, so we’re there driving through perhaps the most peaceful place on the earth, interrupting it all with “BWAAAAAAAAAAA”.
“Norwegian Wood” - One of the most interesting songs on the album in my opinion. It marks the first time George incorporated sitar into a Beatles song. I really want to understand how this went over at the time. Did incorporating eastern music and more experimental sounds into the music of the world's biggest pop stars alienate current fans? Obviously, they did just fine, but it’s hard for me to comprehend any artist shifting their sound so dramatically and not only maintaining their fanbase, but growing it.
“You Won’t See Me” - It’s simple, but I really like the ascending harmonies on the backing vocals singing the titular lyrics in the chorus.
“Think For Yourself” - One of George’s two allotted songs. The fuzzy bass makes it.
“Michelle” - The chord progression and melodies used in the choruses are so captivatingly odd and haunting for a pop song. I know just enough about music theory to know they’re breaking some basic rules here, but not enough to explain it beyond that. It’s up there with “Norwegian Wood” for most interesting songs on “Rubber Soul”.
“I’m Looking Through You” - Love hearing McCartney break out his shouty voice on “You’re not the same”, followed by that little riff on guitar and organ.
“In My Life” - The guitar intro. The harmonized vocals. That harpsichord solo (not an actual harpsichord apparently, but rather a Baroque-style piano recorded an octave down and played back at double the speed).
“Wait”
“If I Needed Someone” - George’s other song on “Rubber Soul”
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
“The Word”
“What Goes On” - Ringo’s allotted track is a country song.
🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
“Girl” - I can appreciate the novelty and innovation of making the sound of sucking teeth a major part of the chorus of your pop song, but this is just one of those nails-on-chalkboard sounds for me. If you’re not similarly affected, I imagine this is a beautiful song for you. I actually really like Fontaines D.C.’s “Starburster”, which employs a similar technique in its chorus.
🌕🌑🌑🌑🌑
“Run For Your Life” - Written by John Lennon (a man who has admitted to hitting women). It’s a song threatening to kill a young woman for pursuing another man. That is…um…bad.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
This album rubbed its soul into my heart
I have always said this was my favorite Beatles album. I think its a fascinating study into such a transitional time for the band, and I love seeing the experimentation bubbling up and it really surprises me just how early this album is: 1965! Obviously much of their work went on to influence nearly the entire musical landscape and I think for many of my favorite bands, it starts here.
Standout tracks for me are "Norwegian Wood" because its perfection and in a bad way "Run For Your Life" because its pretty fucking creepy. Yikes John, yikes.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Overall, I like The Beatles. I was expecting this album to be an easy 4.5 or maybe even a 5.
The stereo mixing on Drive My Car is the first thing that sticks out—right away, this album feels bigger and layered. The harmonies are getting more complex, the instruments they’re using are more unique, and George’s solo has a raw quality that gives it a very retro vibe.
Some tracks feel like a natural evolution (Norwegian Wood already sounds like it belongs on a later Beatles album), while others hold onto their earlier pop sound (You Won’t See Me is straightforward and simple). I imagine there were a lot of conversations about whether to stick to the formula or push beyond it, and this album captures that tension.
The middle section is hit-or-miss. Think for Yourself was a high point, while The Word grated on me with its droning harmonies. Michelle and What Goes On didn’t do much for me either—this stretch of the album feels like a bit of a valley after such a strong start. It starts to recover with Girl, though the chorus (“oh girl [sucks in through teeth] girl”) feels odd. Looking Through You is where it fully finds its footing again.
The final stretch is the strongest. In My Life is one of my all-time favorite Beatles songs, and If I Needed Someone is a high note. Overall, I like where the band is heading here, but the album has its weaker moments—especially in the middle.
Far Out Magazine
Critic’s Review
“In 1965, The Beatles were the biggest band on the planet. With five albums, multiple films and even a cartoon under their belt, Beatlemania was in full swing, allowing the Liverpool lads to tour across the globe. However, as autumn rolled around, the band entered the studio to record album number six – Rubber Soul – marking a turning point in their creative output. The record signifies the band’s progression as mature songwriters and musicians. With Rubber Soul, The Beatles evidently develop their craft, carving out a sound that rings out with considerable individuality…”
Submit Your Review
Weezer [The Blue Album] - Weezer
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
Listen Party: 3/21/25
Released: 1994
Genres: Power Pop, Alternative Rock, Geek Rock, Pop Punk, Emo
Tags: melodic, energetic, male vocalist, bittersweet, summer, playful, anthemic, introspective, lonely, passionate, alienation, longing, anxious, breakup, quirky, melancholic, love, heavy, uplifting, sentimental
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
Oh hells yeah. The first album I know front to back. Listening to it in 2025, instantly brings me back to 2001, playing the songs on guitar with the bassist and singer of my band in a stale-smelling dorm room, lit only by a string of Christmas lights and computer monitors. Since I know the Blue Album well, I'm going to try and do a little research and dive into each of the songs the best that I can.
"My Name is Jonas" - Excellent opening track. I believe it's about escaping into childhood memories while dealing with adult problems? Reddit says Wepeel is the name Rivers Cuomo gave to his sled as a kid. Very Citizen Kane. I don’t know if that’s a troll response, but let's go with it.
"No One Else" - I don't love the controlling, jealous kind of partner Cuomo portrays himself as in this song. "I want a girl who laughs for no one else...when I'm away she never leaves the house". Yick.
"The World Has Turned And Left Me Here" - The fallout from the relationship in "No One Else" with Cuomo feeling lonely after being broken up with. He stated that "No One Else" is about "the jealous-obsessive asshole in me freaking out on my girlfriend," while "'The World Has Turned and Left Me Here’ is the same asshole wondering why she's gone." Self reflection and growth in lyrics? I can get down to that.
"Buddy Holly" - I don't know. It just seems to be about Cuomo's iconic bespectacled appearance. As for the homies dissin' his girl, Cuomo said that the homies were his fellow band members, and that the girl was actually a friend of his in the Santa Monica College Choir. Remember that video though? (It's directed by Spike Jonze, by the way.) I have a strong memory of it being Nirvana, and not Weezer in this video. I could never really understand where that memory came from until I read that Cuomo was inspired by the video for "In Bloom".
"Undone - The Sweater Song" - Cuomo lifted the titular line from his English professor demonstrating the effectiveness of a focused thesis statement. "All I have to do is hold a single thread in your sweater and it will unravel as you walk away." In a 2009 Rolling Stone article, Cuomo admitted to almost completely ripping off Metallica with “Undone's” catchy guitar hook. "I was trying to write a Velvet Underground-type song because I was super into them, and I came up with that guitar riff. I just picked up that acoustic guitar and the first thing I played was that riff...It wasn’t until years after I wrote it that I realized it’s almost a complete rip-off of ‘Sanitarium’ by Metallica. It just perfectly encapsulates Weezer to me – you’re trying to be cool like Velvet Underground but your metal roots just pump through unconsciously."
"Surf Wax America" - This one's fairly self-explanatory. It's Weezer trying to be punk rock Beach Boys. Look, I like the song, but this rhyme in the first verse makes me cringe: "I'm waxing down so that I'll go real fast, I'm waxing down because it's really a blast". Pat Wilson said that none of the band members had ever surfed in their life when they wrote that song.
"Say It Ain't So" - A song about an alcoholic stepfather? Close, but not exactly. Cuomo has said that he had mistakenly blamed the divorce of his mom and biological dad on alcoholism, and that when he found his step-dad's beers in the family fridge years later, he feared the same fate.
"In The Garage" - Just a list of Gen X nerd shit. Authentically Weezer, unlike a certain song about being cool and surfing.
"Holiday" - Beach Boys and Kerouac references. This one always felt like a Green Album song to me. Probably just because the subject matter is similar to "Island in the Sun".
"Only in Dreams" - The kind of love you might only experience in dreams. I love the lyrics, "You can't avoid her, She's in the air, In between molecules, Of oxygen and carbon dioxide" as well as "You walk up to her, Ask her to dance, She says, 'Hey baby, I just might take the chance', You say, 'It's a good thing, That you float in the air, That way there's no way, I will crush your pretty toenails into a thousand pieces". Excellent closing track.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
This is the first album in this project where I truly knew every song very well going in. Still, sitting down to listen closely from start to finish gave me a fresh appreciation for how balanced it is and it’s no wonder it helped launch Weezer to super stardom.
“My Name Is Jonas” opens with a subtle fingerpicking before crashing into the crunchy distorted guitars—a great way to launch an album. They’ll follow this quiet - loud - quiet - loud format throughout the album which gives it a lot of texture. I can tell Rivers Cuomo hadn’t yet entered his “I must write the perfect pop rock song” phase—things are still a little rougher and messier, and Weezer is better for it.
“No One Else” feels a bit problematic, but I’m choosing to believe it’s written from the perspective of a possessive boyfriend and isn’t endorsing the behavior. I find Weezer at their best when Rivers stretches up into the higher register, letting some strain and emotion creep in. And across the whole album, the vocal harmonies are a standout - but particularly on “Holiday”.
“Surf Wax America” is corny, but still a fun singalong. It leans into Beach Boys-era kitsch. And I really like the earnestness with which they sing the falsetto breakdown—especially for a song about taking your surfboard to get to work. I can also understand how others might find the whole thing ridiculous though.
It’s impossible to hear “Buddy Holly” without picturing the Happy Days-style music video—Rivers and the band in their matching sweaters, swaying side to side with smoothed out hair. And right after that comes “The Sweater Song,”. I’ve heard this song hundreds (thousands?) of times, but listening closely now, it strikes me how unconventional it is for a hit. It doesn’t follow any pop rock formula, and that makes it even more interesting.
“Say It Ain’t So” is the true standout—a song about addiction and abuse that still stirs an emotional reaction 30 years later.
The Blue Album is just a little rough around the edges in all the right ways—before the polish came in, before the formulas, just Weezer being melodic, loud, a little weird sometimes, and at the top of their game. Now when are we doing Pinkerton?
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
This album blue its way into my heart
This is probably the hardest review for be because I still have no idea if I like this album.
This album feels like a defining album of middle school for me, because I actively disliked it. I was quite a music snob, combined with being bullied about being a weirdo lead to me not just "not liking" things but standing in opposition to them. This was one of those things. Even with that, much of this album was inescapable and has obviously continued to be a lasting prescience. Now that I'm older and way less judgemental, I was actually excited to revisit this album with new ears.
So where does that leave me? Well I found myself filled with nostalgia from the very first notes. And nostalgia is a hell of a drug. When Buddy Holly or Undone came on, I found myself jumping up off the couch to sing along and play air guitar to. My 14 year old self's feelings of "god this music is simple and shallow and dorky" was countered directly by In The Garage's thesis statement: It's ok to enjoy things. It's ok for music to be fun. It's ok to just let yourself go and play music you want.
Damnit Weezer, how right you are.
So, do I like this album tho?
Not really.
But I certainly can't hate it either.
AllMusic
Critic’s Review
“…that makes for a great record, but more than that, it's a great record emblematic of its time, standing as one of the defining albums of the '90s...”
Submit Your Review
The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Listen Party: 3/20/25
Released: 1989
Genres: Baggy, Jangle Pop, Indie Rock, Neo-Psychedelia, Britpop, C86, Paisley Underground
Scenes: Madchester
Tags: psychedelic, melodic, uplifting, energetic, male vocalist, playful, lush, summer, rhythmic, optimistic, love, ethereal, hypnotic, dense, anthemic, warm, atmospheric, boastful, bittersweet, drugs, romantic, poetic, sensual
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
“I Wanna Be Adored” kicks things off with a slow build that lasts almost two minutes, and when the bass kicks in, it really drives the whole track forward. That dreamy, twangy guitar sound shows up across most of the album. A lot of this album feels like it could be playing in the background of a moody, gritty early ‘90s British indie film.
“She Bangs the Drums” was a major standout—probably the best new song I’ve come across in this whole project so far.
On the whole, I found myself wishing the vocals were a bit more clear. They tend to get lost in the mix, and I’m not sure if that’s just a mixing choice or if the vocals themselves just aren’t that strong. Either way, it made a lot of the songs feel a bit same same after a while, and I found myself unintentionally tuning out.
At times the album has a bit of a psychedelic Beatles LSD-era feel to it - and I wrote that down BEFORE I got to the part where they start reversing tracks. And just when you expect a sitar to show up…it does, on the penultimate track. On the contrary, songs like “I Am the Resurrection” feel more like a jam band session, and while that might be the appeal for some people, it didn’t fully land for me. “Made of Stone” and “This Is the One” pulled me back in with more energy and stronger hooks, but too much of the rest just sort of faded into the background.
And then there’s “Fools Gold”—a strange final track that sounds like a completely different band altogether, with a beat that reminded me of a Fresh Prince era Will Smith song. And I wrote this whole review during the almost 10 minutes it was taking that song to wrap up. I’m not sure how it fits with the rest of the album. Honestly, this would’ve worked better for me as a four-song EP. Look, there’s some great stuff here, but it’s surrounded by a lot filler that’s not for me.
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
This may be the freshest I've ever gone into any album listen. I don't know the album, I don't know any songs by the band, and I've never even heard of The Stone Roses themselves before today. I'll admit though, these tracks are bops.
The Stone Roses are like if Oasis were a jam band. Lots of long, self-indulgent noodling, but I don't mind, because they deliver with catchy hooks in equal part.
"She Bangs the Drums" feels like the kind of optimistic, upbeat song you'd hear in an 80s movie, during a montage in which the main character tries on a bunch of different outfits. It conjures nostalgia without ever having listened to it before.
Don't tell Charles Manson, but "Don't Stop" has that classic backwards-recorded British psychedelia sound from circa 1970.
"Elizabeth My Dear" borrows the melody of medieval tune, "Greensleeves", to take a shot at then-Queen Elizabeth. I'm sure it was a powerful, or at least interesting message in its time, but in 2025 Seattle without any of the social context of 1988 Manchester, it's hard for me to appreciate what they're doing here. If I want to listen to “Greensleeves”, I'll listen to Simon & Garfunkel, thank you very much. Good thing, “Elizabeth My Dear” is only 53 seconds long. It is the one track preventing "The Stone Roses" from being a perfect record in my mind though.
Other than that though, this is a near-perfect album for me, blending pop goodness with artful ambitions. At times you can hear The Stone Roses’ 1980sness, and they emerged from the same Madchester scene that produced New Order. But in my mind, they share more in common with Britpop giants from both their past and their future. When I listen, I hear The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, and Oasis.
Ron 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
I've never heard of The Stone Roses before and even after listening to the album, am pretty sure I've never heard any of their songs before. How have I missed this??? They are SO GOOD.
They sound like a mix between Joe Strummer and the Mescaleros, The Who, Phish, and maybe The Beach Boys? Occasionally toss in some jazz or funk and you've got The Stone Roses. I really like how each track seems to be so different and it felt sort of experimental, like they were testing out different styles and asking themselves "is this our sound?"
Their self-titled album is incredibly solid but I really found the opening and ending tracks to be my favorites. This Is The One and Waterfall are probably my favorite tracks on the album because they are both so dynamic. The perfect road trip songs. I usually pick out a stinker but I don't think this album has one!
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
This album rose its way into my heart.
I came in like a fresh spring daisy never having heard of the band let alone the album and was pleasantly surprised!
I put this album on while i was at work and was instantly transported into a land of "oh hell yeah!" While it's admittedly not the best listening experience, I found myself just grooving along with the music and took notice at several points.
After it ended I just came away with "Dangggg how have I never heard this before?!"
Rolling Stone
Critic’s Review
“By the time they had released The Stone Roses, they had at least half a dozen fantastic songs.”
Submit Your Review
Hot Fuss - The Killers
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Listen Party: 3/19/25
Released: 2004
Genres: Post-Punk Revival, Pop Rock, New Wave, Synthpop, Big Music
Tags: male vocalist, melodic, energetic, bittersweet, anthemic, anxious, romantic, rhythmic, passionate, introspective, sexual, melancholic, urban, love, longing
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Hot Fuss is one of the first albums in this project where I already knew most of the songs. That said, I tried not to let nostalgia or familiarity get in the way or influence the rating too much. I’ve heard these tracks in stores, commercials, and everywhere else for the past two decades, but sitting down to actually listen from front to back gave me an appreciation for just how many hits come from this one record - it’s kind of wild that they didn’t come from two or three separate records like they did in my memory.
“Mr. Brightside” is still good, even if it’s been played to death, “Smile Like You Mean It” feels like a bit of a dip in the momentum after such a strong start. “Somebody Told Me” was the first single or the first song from The Killers I ever heard, but it hasn’t aged quite as well—especially against some of the other mega hits from this album. “All These Things That I’ve Done” holds up way better, and I always loved the gospel build up.
The Euro-pop intro of “On Top” feels like a leftover from late-‘90s, but it quickly finds its footing in The Killersverse. “Everything Will Be Alright” was a standout for me this time around, and honestly would’ve made a better album closer.
The Killers are a weird band to place—Mormons from Vegas who somehow became a UK obsession—but Hot Fuss still mostly holds its own.
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
“Hot Fuss” is the first album from the Strange New Places project that feels fully from my era. Despite that, I have never listened to this album all the way through.
It starts off strongly, with SO MANY familiar songs - "Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine", "Mr. Brightside", "Smile Like You Mean It", "Somebody Told Me" and "All These Things That I've Done". All certified bangers in their time. And though some suffered from overexposure, two decades later, I think they've all held up quite well.
But could somebody tell me what "Somebody Told Me" is about? Is it referring to Brandon Flowers dating a pre-transition trans man? Or a trans woman who detransitioned? Or someone who switches genders when dating different people? I know the trans angle is a tempting read on the chorus's lyrics, but I'm not sure that's it. The rest of the song seems to be about trying and failing to get someone's attention in the club. With that in mind, is the chorus simply a "hey girl, we got similar tastes in romantic partners - wanna fuck about it?"
The Killers never had The Strokes' cool-kid cachet, but the almost-bored vocal delivery of "Change Your Mind" could easily be imported from "Is This It", and the synth line could be swapped with The Strokes’ distinctive lead guitar. In fact, Flowers himself said, "The Strokes’ first record came out and we ditched everything we wrote except for 'Mr. Brightside’ and started again, because that record’s so good, you know? It was just…we realized that they raised the bar. Whether The Strokes know it or not, they really changed our path.”
After nearly an album full of anthemic rock, the lower energy "Everything Will Be Alright" was a near-skip for me, then the mid-song keys came in with their pleasant backing rhythm and melody. I'm glad I gave it a shot. The song is such a groove.
I learned from Just John, that’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™’s review, that The Killers are Mormon. It surprised me because, between “Mr. Brightside”, “Somebody Told Me”, and “Midnight Show”, “Hot Fuss” is so horny.
I didn't expect to give this album five stars moons, but there's not a single bad song on here. Or to paraphrase Sum 41, it's all Killers and no fillers. What can I say? It's indie rock'n'roll for me.
Ron 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
I didn't like every song on the album but it still deserves 5 stars (I only disliked Everything Will Be Alright but I really, really disliked it; sorry fans of the song).
I didn't realize how many of the songs on this album were singles, which really shows how good the album is as a whole. I'll skip reviewing them since they have proven themselves individually. As a whole, the singles still slap and if they ever come on the radio/random I'm always jamming along.
The standout in the album for me has to be Believe Me Natalie. I'm a huge fan of dynamic rhythm changes and this has a lot of them. The beginning sort of reminds me of a 30 Seconds to Mars song, who I also enjoy listening to.
I think The Killers do a good job of "having a sound" without being repetitive or one-note. Minus the one stinker, this is an album that gets regular plays and evokes a lot of nostalgia for me.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
This album fussed its way into my heart.
This album certainly came out when I was in my "too cool for current popular music" phase, and while I recognized most of the hits I wouldn't say that these were songs I knew going in. That being said, The Killers certainly know how to make a song that feels familiar. Just about every song felt like I could've heard it before and seemed to be inviting me to sing along the next time the chorus came around.
Missing from this album for me was dynamic range. Every song kind of felt like it was at the same level and even within a song, most choruses were at the same level as the verses with the only difference being: "Oh this is the catchy part." I wish there was just a bit more variance, and consequently my favorite parts were when the synth got more prominent and broke up this sort of homogeneity. I also dug Everything Will Be Alright since it stood out so much and made me take notice.
The album as a whole tho? It fine.
Spin
Critic’s Review
While "Mr. Brightside" and "Somebody Told Me" evinced Brandon Flowers' gift for pop, the radiance of "All These Things That I've Done" suggested goals higher than sales.
Submit Your Review
Listen Party: 3/18/25
Released: 1990
Genres: Alternative Rock, Indie Rock, Surf Rock, Post-Punk
Tags: energetic, male vocalist, anxious, noisy, melodic, quirky, science fiction, warm, rhythmic, abstract, summer, love, female vocalist, psychedelic
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
I've always had an appreciation for goofy, silly, weird rock outfits that don't take themselves too seriously. The Presidents of the United States of America and The Aquabats come to mind. I've long thought of Pixies to be a more avant garde and critically-acclaimed version of that. Like I can’t name a single “funny” song by them, but some songs have kind of a “funny” sound. Do you know what I mean?
To be fair, I've only ever known their hits, and let's face it - this is Bossanova and not Surfer Rosa. But hey, those names rhyme; maybe it'll be good! It does seem that critical reception of the album was that of disappointment after back-to-back masterpieces in Surfer Rosa and Doolittle. But maybe that makes Bossanova the perfect starting place for a Pixies novice. No room for disappointment when you've never experienced full-on appointment.
One review I read called them Surf Rock for Goth kids, which I found hilariously accurate. As a Boston-based outfit, they're still geographically closer to California than they are to their Crawley, England contemporaries, The Cure. But you can hear some similar production in the guitar and vocals.
"Velouria" and "Dig for Fire" are the singles off this album, and for good reason. They're among the best. I also enjoyed "Cecilia Ann", "Rock Music", "Allison", "Is She Weird", "The Happening", "Hang Wire", "Stormy Weather", and "Havalina".
Ron 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Bossanova is overall a great album that has just a couple stinkers (Rock Music and Ana, I'm looking at you). I appreciate that they are pioneers and super artsy when its comes to the genre but the ones that I didn't like really, really brought me out of that "listen to the whole album" high you can sometimes get. Maybe I just don't get these songs?
That being said, Hang Wire and Havalina are my faves for the album and given they are both at the end of the album I always walk away with a good vibe.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
Bossa Nova is my first time listening to a full Pixies album, even though I’ve heard their name for years through the bands they’ve influenced. I didn’t expect it to open with a surf rock instrumental, but it sets the tone that this is an album that isn’t following conventions. “Rock Music” lives up to its title, but the shouting just isn’t really for me—and repeating “your mouth is a mile away” over and over with just the occasional left turn further establishes that this is not a pop rock album.
The next few songs get a bit more tuneful, but they still don’t play by any traditional song structure rules. This isn’t a verse-chorus-verse-chorus kind of band. The lyrics are surreal—“how does lemur skin reflect the sea” is one that stuck with me—and the whole album feels like a bridge between Bowie and ‘90s alternative. You can hear the blueprint for a lot of later music here, especially for bands that kept some of the rage and edge, but packaged it into something more radio-friendly.
“Dig for Fire” was a clear standout and wouldn’t feel out of place on a Modest Mouse record. “Havelina” closes things out on a surprisingly calm, mellow note—far from the chaos the album started with.
Liz
🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
This album bossanova'ed its way into my heart
This is a delightful album packed with short snappy songs. I had a lot of fun listening to this album with it's distinctive "Pixies" sound, and its pretty solid the whole way thru. I was actually pretty surprised that the chorus of "Is She Weird" was in three bar phrases, which is pretty unusual for this style of music and gives it an off kilter and almost rushed feel. Kim Deal's bass lines are always a delight. While I had a good time, this album didn't really grab me or take me places. It's good. But not great.
A perfect album to put on for a road trip.
Dan
🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
This album reminds me of the goth kids who hung out in the mall food court. They think they're weird, and they actually are weird, just not in the way they think they are. The lyrics are totally nonsensical and the music fits that vibe. There's no continuity to the album, jumping from surf music to screaming rock to a weird Talking Heads clone. It's hard for me to like this album at all because I don't love it on it's technical merits, and just can't get into it personally.
Rolling Stone
Critic’s Review
Doolittle — The Pixies’ third album and big-label debut — was one of 1989’s most acclaimed releases; it garnered truckloads of critical hosannas for its disturbing, dizzying variations on alternative-guitar-rock themes. For the follow-up, the Boston foursome could have kept drawing from the same well, but Bossanova is a pretty far cry from its predecessor.
Submit Your Review
Tracy Chapman - Tracy ChapMan
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Listen Party: 3/17/25
Released: 1988
Genres: Singer-Songwriter, Folk Rock, Folk Pop, Acoustic Rock, Heartland Rock
Tags: conscious, female vocalist, political, love, melancholic, sentimental, melodic, acoustic, passionate, androgynous vocals, protest, bittersweet, philosophical
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
Oh Tracy Chapman, what a pleasure it was to listen to your self-titled album. I think even casual listeners such as myself will recognize the first two songs: "Talkin' Bout a Revolution" and of course, "Fast Car". And if they're anything like me, they might be surprised by the 1980s release date on this album. I always assumed that Chapman's rise to fame happened during the 90s, and even after listening to this album, it's hard to imagine it in an 80s context. This was the era of George Michael and Tiffany.
"Across the Lines" and "Behind the Wall" could have very well been written during the height of the Black Lives Matter protests, and are painful reminders that very little has changed in the nearly 40 years since Chapman's first release.
The synthesized pan flutes in "Mountains O' Things" feel corny and of-their-moment, but do not detract from the song's anti-commercialism message.
"She's Got Her Ticket" pleasantly surprises by introducing a roots reggae beat to Chapman's iconic dusky, folksy sound.
There has been much speculation about Chapman's sexuality over the years. She has been outed by former partners, but has never publicly claimed a lesbian, bisexual or queer identity. Lyrics in songs about love and heartbreak like, "Baby Can I Hold You", "For My Lover", and "If Not Now..." seem to be kept intentionally vague. Even the closing track, "For You", seems to be more about Chapman herself than whatever romantic partner it's seemingly directed at. I imagine that in the 1980s, the conspicuously missing he/him pronouns from love songs were an enormous wink and a nod to the LGBTQ community. Chapman hasn't released an album since 2008, but I can't help but wonder what she thinks of current Bedroom Pop starlets like Clairo, Girl in Red, and Billie Eilish fully dropping the veil in their lyrics. I hope she’d be proud of the progress.
rON 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Ok, clearly Fast Car is an amazing song and holds up to this day. What about the rest of the album, though? I think so!
I'd normally criticize other artists for being too simple in regards to songs like Behind the Wall and For You, but for some reason Tracy makes the simplicity really shine. Like my favorite Italian foods, its about fresh ingredients being showcased upfront... and Tracy has some of the freshest out there. Her voice is amazing and super nostalgic.
The rest of the album is good, but its hard to compare to Fast Car and Baby Can I Hold you. I really appreciate how she had to walk a fine line between powerful lyrics and general acceptance, given the time of this album's release. I'd love to sit down with her and ask if she would change any of the lyrics if she were to re-write them now.
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Tracy Chapman opens with “Talkin’ ‘Bout a Revolution,” a song I first knew from a Reel Big Fish cover—which, it turns out, doesn’t even come close to the original. Right away, Chapman’s voice cuts through everything and is totally unmistakable. The gospel-sounding organ in the background adds a nice touch that sets the tone for the rest of the album.
“Fast Car” is the song I’ve heard more than any other in this project so far, and it still hits hard—even after it was brought back into the spotlight by Luke Combs’ cover a few years ago. After those first two tracks, there’s a bit of a fall off, but there’s still plenty to appreciate. The haunting delivery on “Behind the Wall” is one of the most powerful moments here, tackling domestic violence and police inaction with just her voice. Some songs, like “Baby Can I Hold You,” feel a little dated now, which holds the album back from being perfect in my opinion.
There’s a bit of reggae in “She’s Got Her Ticket,” and the lyric “Love is hate, war is peace, no is yes” sounds straight out of a dystopian novel. Chapman might open the album talking about a revolution coming, but most of what she’s singing about is still fairly relevant nearly 40 years after the fact.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
This album self titled its way into my heart
Listening to this near perfect album last night was a straight up gut punch. What a masterpiece of a debut album from Tracy Chapman. From the very first track it was song after song of incredible lyrics with impeccable vocals delivered straight into my soul.
With songs touching on everything from heartbreak to poverty to race relations to policing to wealth inequality to domestic violence this album feels as important now as in 1987. Kicking off with "Talkin' Bout a Revolution", Chapman takes no quarter forcing you to sit up and confront what this album is going to be about. While "Fast Car" is obviously a standout and deserves all the accolades it has gotten, the stark delivery of "Behind the Wall" haunts me. The choice to not only have the song be entirely vocals with no backing, but to be mixed so incredibly dry, with little to no processing and reverb, is incredibly bold and makes the songs story impossible to ignore.
I've always liked Chapman's music, at least the songs I've heard, but this was the first time i listened to one of her albums fully. I've been missing out.
Dan 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
I've always liked "Fast Car" and while the song has a sad tone, I never really listened to the lyrics. It starts optimistic and quickly I find I'm just jamming along without thinking about it anymore. Tracy Chapman joins some of the best artists by masking intense reality behind catchy tracks.
As an absolutely generic white guy who has lived a safe and comfortable life, I can't relate to the challenges that run through the album. In spite of that, the sincerity and emotion in the vocals, lyrics, and music make it impossible not to feel it all in a visceral way.
There are hardly any duds in the album (Looking at you "Baby can I hold you", how was this one a single). She nails the a cappella track "Behind the Wall", proving her vocals absolutely stand on their own. The variety in style and instruments keeps it interesting all the way through. Overall an impressive album that has great depth and replayability.
Sputnik Music
Critic’s Review
Upon first listening to Tracy Chapman's seminal, eponymous debut, one can perhaps be a little too quick to speculate upon its influences. Whilst it is undeniable that the record is a shining example of classic contemporary (excuse the oxymoron) folk- and is indeed deservedly held in such high regard- classifying this as simply a folk album would be selling Chapman, her background and her resultant musical efforts woefully short. There is no doubt that the socio-politically charged lyrics are reminiscent of the heyday of revered legends such as Bob Dylan and Joan Baez, one should take into account of Tracy Chapman's upbringing; while the aforementioned artists were making their waves, Chapman was growing up in a working-class African-American neighbourhood, nigh unreachable by white folk artists despite the sympathetic lyrical content of their works. Despite the thematic similarities, closer examination of the music, particularly that of her 1988 debut, reveals more in common with country, 70's R&B and soul.
The album kicks off with the famous, energetic number 'Talkin' Bout a Revolution', which begins with a simple but catchy acoustic guitar rhythm and Chapman's idiosyncratic, husky crooning, with percussion being gradually added as the song builds momentum. The lyrics are powerful and evocative, conjuring images of the proletariat on their welfare lines, with “whispers” of rising up. Indeed, the song is a typical but wonderful example of Chapman's talent for creating thought-provoking yet uncomplicated songs, a style of 'depth through simplicity', if you will. Though it would be famously covered by Living Color, Chapman's version remains a signature song both for her and in the mindset of the lower social classes. Indeed, despite being a definitive contemporary folk number, one can hear influences of the more socially-conscious works of Stevie Wonder and James Brown rather than Dylan.
Another highlight of the album is the second track, which almost anyone who listens to music outside of the pop charts should know. 'Fast Car' is a more sombre cut, telling the story of a young woman who wishes to break free from her troubled life, having dropped out of school to look after her ailing father abandoned by his wife for his drinking and unemployment, wanting “more from life than he could give”. The narrator describes her life in stages through each gentle verse over the distinctive guitar melody, leaving with her partner in his titular car hoping for a better life but finding herself stuck in the same rut, all the while harkening back in the more uplifting refrains to the excitement and hope she had felt when driving in her man's fast car. Whilst a hit single, the song is also aware of similar stories that befell many a young person in hard times, leaving a bitter aftertaste when one realizes that sometimes they just can't escape.
Other tracks that convey the consciousness of the societal-challenged include the brief yet memorably haunting a capella 'Behind The Wall', describing the social injustices of her brethren, 'Across The Lines' which explicitly details acts of violence against citizens considered second-class and how they are ignored in favour of the lesser strife of the dominant whites. 'Mountain O' Things' further explores the disparities between the wealthy and the poverty stricken, all the while keeping in line with her simplistic but methodical approach to songwriting.
However, there are also tracks that delve deeper into Chapman's own personal psyche. The introspective, soulful 'Baby Can I Hold You' is another famous track off the record, which no amount of covers from forgettable boy bands of the 90s could ever destroy. Similarly, songs like 'For My Lover' and 'For You' continue to examine personal feelings of love and the effects it has on life, but also the effects life has on love. This is not an album split thematically down the middle, with one half being socio-politcal and the other a collection of love ballads, but rather they are interwoven beautifully and memorably, resonating deeply with any listener who can form any sort of connection to the soulful and at times mournful lyrics.
It would be doing the album an immense disservice to simply call it folk and consign it to the ages as such. Indeed, many of the tracks are relevant to society even today, especially when one casts thoughts to the dreadful conflict in Gaza, but also to the world as a whole, still in various stages of recovery from the worst economic downturn in many decades. Chapman's insistence of maintaining the integrity of her songs as she originally intended has led to her first album becoming a truly timeless work. Sure, the simplistic approach to each song won't sit well with everyone but it is through the simplicity that Chapman effectively conveys her message. With her range of influences outside of the obvious, Chapman was able to make the work of a single black woman from Cleveland relevant to a myriad peoples the world over, evidenced by the massive sales of the record. At a time when popular music was saturated with cheesy synthesizer lines over electronic dance beats and generic party lyrics, Chapman's effort and success is made all the more commendable.
Submit Your Review
Court and Spark - Joni Mitchell
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
Listen Party: 3/14/25
Released: 1974
Genres: Singer-Songwriter, Folk Pop, Jazz Pop, Soft Rock, Progressive Pop
Tags: female vocalist, poetic, lush, introspective, melodic, soft, love, mellow, bittersweet, longing, romantic, passionate, acoustic, warm
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
“Court and Spark” is more polished and confident than I expected. I didn't recognize a single song off this album, and I guess I didn't know that much about Joni Mitchell. Here, she sounds at ease singing about love and heartbreak, which is a departure from the activism or social commentary I was expecting. There are many grooving interludes to the songs, with some moments feeling like they were pulled straight out of a classic rock song, which were no doubt popular and surrounding Joni while this album was being written.
By track four, the signature bright, shimmering guitar sounds I associate as unmistakable Joni Mitchell appear for the first time, but quickly retreat again for the rest of the album, making way for more surprises. The electric piano in ‘Car on a Hill’ sounds like it could be ripped from the score of a gritty 1970's police procedural, and ‘Down to You’ leaves nothing on the cutting room floor as it wanders through an elaborate film score soundscape with a mix of instruments that leaves no instrument from the middle school band room untouched.
Is it wrong to compare Joni Mitchell to Taylor Swift? Songs about vague ex-lovers, and savage lines like,
"dreaming of the pleasure I'm going to have watching your hairline recede"
certainly make the comparison easier. The jazzy closer ‘Twisted’ is the exclamation point on the album, showing off yet another trick and musical style I didn't know Joni had.
Claire 🌕🌗🌑🌑🌑
I know her name well, but I don't think I could identify a single Joni Mitchell song before this listen. I imagined something a little more granola-crunchy, and a lot less adult contemporary. She has a very pretty voice, but this genre is not for me. Maybe if "Court and Spark" were produced in a context other than the mid-70s, I could get behind it. But as is, I'm not a fan.
I'll admit though, that 'Raised on Robbery' is fun and has a sax solo that I don't hate. It may be the most rock-n-roll song on the album. The last track, 'Twisted', is also a good time, but much jazzier. And while the music isn't to my taste, the lyrics of 'Down to You' caught my attention.
"You go down to the pickup station
Craving warmth and beauty
You settle for less than fascination
Few drinks later, you're not so choosy
When the closing lights strip off the shadows
On this strange new flesh you've found
Clutching the night to you like a fig leaf, you hurry
To the blackness and the blankets"
That is a damn poetic verse about a one-night stand.
Finally, Mitchell's voice is a glissando machine. She can't even help it. Whether in the recording studio or on the mall escalator, she’s just glissandoing all over the place. But what can I say? That’s Joni Mitchell for ya. 🤷♀️
Liz 🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
This album courted its way into my heart.
There is a lot to like about this album that ultimately I don't get along with. My issues with this album stem almost entirely from its production. The star of the album is clearly Joni's voice, and consequently the album is at its best when it's in the most pared-down, singer-song writer form as it is in the title track. Piano, some light backing, and Joni's vocals are really all it needs.
The production issues for me are two-fold. The first is that the songs feel too crowded. It feels like the producers were trying to make this album sound big, but it ends up feeling very dated and stifling. Orchestral arrangements and saxophone feel out of place.
My second issue with the production is in the mix which has a harshness to it. There are some mid-high frequencies that are extremely prominent across the entire instrumentation that I think are supposed to give the album an energy, but ultimately end up just fatiguing my ear before the second song is over. And given how rich Joni's vocals are, it makes her fatiguing to listen to.
All in all, a good album hidden by poor production decisions.
Ron 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Joni Mitchell is a name I would recognize but I probably wouldn't have been able to tell you who she was or why she was known until now.
I thought Court and Spark was a really solid album. Joni's voice is beautiful and easy to listen to for long periods of time. A lot of the songs in this album have some strong jazz influence, of which I'm a huge fan. That being said, some of them were a bit too old fashioned for my taste, like Trouble Child. Down To You is my standout song on this album and will likely make into a playlist or two of mine in the future.
Dan 🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
The album is a series of disconnected stream of consciousness ramblings with a general theme of stress and unhappiness. I assume Joni Mitchell just took her therapy journal and set it to music. As a hippy swept up into a life of fame, she's got a lot to work through. Also, her romantic relationships aren't what I'd call healthy: a wandering busker, a gambler and "sweet talking ladies man", a dude who ghosts her up on a hill. Pull it together, lady.
Joni has a sweet voice, but none of the songs really pop. "Raised on Robbery" starts hard as hell for about 15 seconds, but the clavinet and close harmony fusion is immediately set aside for the boring, heavily produced adult contemporary that runs through this album.
This album is critically acclaimed so I'm sure people who understand music better than me think I'm an idiot. They can't stop me from giving this thing 2/5 moons, though.
Brooke 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗
Very nice, very chill. Good to have in the background, felt like good traveling music if one were to go on a road trip.
Avi 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
Enjoyed the instrumentation, vocalists voice and how they sing is pleasant. It had a nice chill energy to it that got a bit more frantic in some songs, and it was an enjoyable listen.
Barry Walsh
Critic’s Review
Before there was Alanis, Fiona, Tori, or any handful of female singer-songwriters with a predilection for painfully confessional lyrics, there was Canadian-born folk-pop chanteuse Joni Mitchell. Mitchell carved out similar territory as her recent followers, but with a poetic beauty that still seems to elude the new breed. And that poetic beauty, colored by flourishes of ‘70s jazz-pop, makes Mitchell’s 1974 opus Court and Spark one of that decade’s most enduring pop pleasures. Incorporating orchestral swirls, stacks of vocals, and contributions from a wide array of musicians (including guitarists Larry Carlton, Jose Feliciano, and Robbie Robertson, trumpet player Chuck Findley, and backing vocalists David Crosby, Graham Nash, and, um, Cheech and Chong), Mitchell’s gifts for melody and arrangement are most vividly demonstrated on sumptuous tracks like the Top 10 single “Help Me,” the reflective “People’s Parties,” and the adventurous “Car On the Hill,” which stitches together song parts with stretches of multi-tracked harmonies, the end result being nearly hallucinatory.
Lyrically, Mitchell is at her sharpest—and occasionally wittiest—on tracks such as the album’s jaunty first single “Raised On Robbery,” the light n’ jazzy “Free Man In Paris” (long said to be about record exec David Geffen) and the aforementioned “People’s Parties.” Whether she’s ruminating on love found and lost (capturing the quagmire of emotions with one simple line: “Laughing and crying/You know it’s the same release”) or the pitfalls of her newfound celebrity (she would continue to rally against “the star-making machinery behind the popular songs” throughout her career), Mitchell is, with Court and Spark, represented at the peak of her talents for crafting song-stories that are simultaneously inventive, intricate, and unfailingly melodic. And while many of today’s artists have exhibited shades of such talent, not many—of either gender—have been able to match such a dizzying height. Thus, also taking into consideration its mid-‘70s California dreaminess, Court and Spark is not only the best soundtrack to a Sunday morning ever made, it’s also an essential, timeless artifact of an era when pop could be both popular and personal, and would be rewarded critically and commercially for such qualities.
Submit Your Review
Listen Party: 3/13/25
Released: 1963
Genres: Contemporary Folk, Singer-Songwriter, Acoustic Blues, Talking Blues
Scenes: Greenwich Village Scene
Tags: poetic, acoustic, protest, political, male vocalist, conscious, mellow, introspective, autumn, passionate, bittersweet, humorous, philosophical, warm, melodic, melancholic, playful, war, breakup, love, romantic, sarcastic
Just John, That’s it, that’s the reviewer’s name™
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
“The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan” starts off with ‘Blowin’ in the Wind,’ a song everyone knows, and it really sets the tone for the rest of the album - this is Bob fuckin’ Dylan, in case you were expecting something else. ‘Masters of War’ is one of the more powerful tracks, with a driving chord progression that just keeps pushing forward like an old engine. It barely shifts, dipping for a brief retreat before driving straight back into the steady anger.
The whole album feels rough around the edges and I guess that’s the point. Dylan’s guitar sounds a little out of tune sometimes, but it fits the vibe. “A Hard Rain’s A-Gonna Fall” stood out for its slow build and big chorus, but the highlight is, not surprisingly, “Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right”—one of the only songs I knew going in, and still the one that hit hardest.
Liz 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
This album freewheeled its way into my heart.
This album definitely takes me back to high school when I was listening to Dylan on repeat. It's been a few years though, so giving this album a listen as a more singular experience (as opposed to having a bunch of Dylan all on shuffle) was fascinating. There are certainly some great songs on here and overall a good album, but not necessarily a favorite.
Claire 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
At 42 years old, I can’t remember a time when I didn’t recognize Bob Dylan’s iconic sound, and for just as long, I’ve appreciated his unique vocal delivery. That said, I don’t think I’ve ever listened to an album of his all the way through, and I’m not sure that I actually know more than a handful of his tunes.
‘Blowin’ in the Wind’, is one of those songs I knew, and its position as the first track of “The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan”, gave me hope that maybe I’d know more tracks off of this album. Alas, it was the only tune I recognized. My first recollection of hearing this song, was when Jenny performs it on an acoustic guitar in a strip club in the film, “Forrest Gump”. Wikipedia tells me that it was Joan Baez who popularized the song, but Bob Dylan did indeed write it. The melody is from an old Negro spiritual called ‘No More Auction Block’.
As for the album itself, I quite enjoyed the more melodic tracks. The B-side is stacked in that regard. I expected folksy, which “Freewheelin’” delivers on, but it’s also bluesier than I had anticipated. Seeing as Dylan is a well-known harmonica player, I’m thinking that’s probably on me.
Brooke 🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
So I don't hear lyrics, but the beginning part of the album sounded like we were in the Mississippi bayou and crawled our way west into the blazing sun with our pouch of water running dry. Stopped in a city and turned our eyes north toward the wet and slick streets of a northern metropolis and found naught but woe and worry wherever we went.
If I were to say what "Americana" felt like to me, this album would come to mind.
The harmonica wailed, and so did my ears.
Ron 🌕🌕🌑🌑🌑
I’m not a huge fan of Bob Dylan but I can see how he has influenced music in the generations after him (Tom Petty seems to be the most direct influence and I like his music). I liked ‘Oxford Town’ the best but honestly most of the rest of the songs sounded very similar to each other.
Dan 🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑
There are a couple catchy tunes despite only having a harmonica and guitar. The political stuff is super heavy handed and comes across as naive even if his heart is in the right place. He's only 21 years old here and doesn't have to deal with 24 hour news/social media, so I'm going to give him a pass.
’Bob Dylan’s Dream’ has my favorite lyrics, but largely because I'm a sucker for nostalgia and old friends.
Roughly every other song is about some woman who sounds pretty chill in the lyrics, but he's being a passive-aggressive dick to her anyway.
Bob Dylan freewheeled himself to half the moons I have to give.
The Jukebox Rebel
Critic's Review
He may have kept his cards close to his chest on last year’s debut album, but here he laid down his winning hand (12 of his own) and, holy shmoly, he was ace of spades and king o’ diamonds all in one. The musical template remains very much the same – century old folk traditions upheld via one man and his all–round agility on guitar picks and strums, vocal phrasings hitherto unheard, and a harmonica laced with a winning warmth. Lyrically, it’s a whole new ball game. Although he retains the personal relationship themes and an appealing sprinkle of surrealism and dry humour, there’s a new character developing – this is Bob Dylan, political activist, social agitator, news commentator. Bob gets stuck into topics many and varied, with no holding back – “tin pan alley folk music”, “warmongers” and “racists” are all confronted, sometimes head-on from an angry Bob, sometimes from a sarcastic, scornful Bob. Always, he knows his topics well before he starts singing.
“Masters of War” is the album’s highlight for me – a bullshit free, stare it out, shout it down condemnation of War, an event which seemed almost inevitable at the height of the Cuban Missile Crisis. The song’s incessant melody line was adapted from Jean Ritchie’s 1957 arrangement of the traditional “Nottamun Town”, and Bob uses it to underline his verbal assault, as he takes on the power brokers at their own aggressive game: “I think you will find, when your death takes its toll, all the money you made will never buy back your soul”. Of the song, Dylan himself said: “I’ve never written anything like that before. I don’t sing songs which hope people will die, but I couldn’t help it with this one. The song is a sort of striking out… a feeling of what can you do?”
As if to remind that he’s not gonna be an earnest bore “Bob Dylan’s Blues” has a great sense of fun, more of that sing-talk style as groupies and playboys get the short shrift with lines like “All you five and ten cent women, with nothin’ in your heads, I got a real gal I’m in love” and “I don’t have no sports car, and I don’t even care to have one, I can walk anytime around the block”.
It’s not long ‘til he’s back on the serious topics of the day via “A Hard Rain’s A-Gonna Fall”. With the very real threat of war hanging over the country, Dylan protests that we should beware propaganda and seek out the truth for ourselves, (“the pellets of poison are flooding the waters”) and warns of the consequences of escalation (“I’ve walked and I’ve crawled on six crooked highways, I’ve stepped in the middle of seven sad forests, I’ve been out in front of a dozen dead oceans”). In his album notes, Bob explained a little of the background to his epic 5 verse q & a masterpiece: “Every line in it is actually the start of a whole song, but when I wrote it, I thought I wouldn’t have enough time alive to write all those songs so I put all I could into this one.”
There’s absolutely no doubt we were witnessing a genius at work – with its jaw dropping insight, this album stops you dead in your tracks one minute, then breaks the tension with irreverent craziness the next. You don’t whether to laugh or cry. What a player. What a wordsmith. What soul. What an album…